Retailer Reviews

Leibish & Co. Diamonds Review

This page contains references to diamonds or engagement rings from different companies. Sometimes I do receive a commission when you click on links and buy the products.


Leibish & Co. is a leading name in the world of colored diamonds and gemstone jewelry, dedicated to providing exceptional quality, unparalleled craftsmanship, and innovative design. As a family-owned business with a deep passion for rare and vibrant stones, Leibish & Co. has become a go-to destination for those seeking one-of-a-kind engagement rings and fine jewelry. In this review, we will delve into the company's history, commitment to diamond and gemstone quality, unique engagement ring collections, meticulous design and craftsmanship, pricing and value, and the overall Leibish experience.


History of Leibish & Co.

Founded in 1979 by Leibish Polnauer, Leibish & Co. began as a small business with a strong focus on quality and customer satisfaction. Over the years, the company has evolved into a global leader in the world of colored diamonds and gemstones, driven by the vision of creating extraordinary pieces that celebrate life's most memorable moments.

Leibish Homepage

Leibish & Co. quickly gained recognition in the industry for its expertise in colored diamonds, also known as "fancy" diamonds. As one of the first companies to embrace the beauty and rarity of these vibrant stones, Leibish & Co. has cultivated a diverse and captivating collection that attracts clients from around the world.

With an unwavering commitment to excellence, Leibish & Co. has expanded its international presence, with offices in New York, Hong Kong, and Tel Aviv, while maintaining its family-owned roots and personalized approach to customer service. Today, Leibish & Co. is celebrated for its distinctive designs, exceptional craftsmanship, and passion for the world of colorful brilliance.

Leibish Diamond and Gemstone Quality

Leibish & Co. is deeply committed to sourcing high-quality colored diamonds and gemstones, ensuring that each piece of jewelry they create showcases the extraordinary beauty and rarity of these vibrant stones. The company adheres to strict grading standards, working closely with the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) to ensure that every diamond in their collection is certified and accurately represented.

Pink oval diamonds from Leibish

All of the diamonds sold by Leibish & Co. come with GIA reports, which is a significant advantage for customers. These reports provide a comprehensive evaluation of each diamond, including details about the stone's color, clarity, carat weight, and cut. This commitment to transparency and accuracy instills confidence in customers, knowing that the quality and authenticity of their purchase are backed by the world's most trusted gemological authority.

When it comes to colored diamonds, Leibish & Co. is an excellent option, offering a wide range of colors, cuts, and sizes to suit every taste and budget. Their expertise in the niche of colored diamonds sets them apart from other jewelers, making them a top choice for those seeking a unique and vibrant engagement ring or piece of fine jewelry.

However, for customers seeking "colorless" diamonds, it's essential to consider other reputable companies such as Whiteflash, James Allen, and Blue Nile. These companies specialize in colorless diamonds and provide a broad selection, competitive pricing, and exceptional quality. In fact James Allen and Blue Nile also provide colored diamonds as well.

In conclusion, Leibish & Co.'s dedication to diamond and gemstone quality is evident in their commitment to GIA certification and their expertise in colored diamonds. While they are a top choice for colored diamonds, customers seeking colorless diamonds should also explore options offered by Whiteflash, James Allen, and Blue Nile to find the perfect stone that meets their specific requirements and preferences.

Leibish Engagement Ring Collections

Leibish & Co. offers an extensive range of engagement ring collections that showcase the exceptional beauty and vibrant colors of their diamonds and gemstones. Each collection features unique designs, incorporating various combinations of colored diamonds, complementary gemstones, and precious metals. Here is an overview of some popular Leibish engagement ring collections:

a. Fancy Color Diamond Collection: This collection highlights the breathtaking beauty of colored diamonds, featuring stones in various hues, including yellow, pink, blue, green, and more. The rings in this collection are designed to accentuate the natural color of the diamonds, resulting in stunning and eye-catching pieces.

b. Colored Diamond and Gemstone Collection: For those seeking a unique and colorful combination, the Colored Diamond and Gemstone Collection features rings that pair colored diamonds with complementary gemstones such as sapphires, rubies, and emeralds. These designs create a harmonious and visually striking contrast, perfect for those who desire a distinctive and unforgettable engagement ring.

c. Halo Collection: The Halo Collection features engagement rings with a halo of smaller diamonds surrounding the center stone. The halo enhances the brilliance and size of the centerpiece, creating a spectacular effect. This collection includes rings with both colorless and colored diamonds, offering a variety of options for those who love the halo style.

d. Solitaire Collection: The Solitaire Collection emphasizes the simplicity and elegance of a single diamond, set in a refined and minimalistic setting. This collection offers a variety of color options and settings, allowing customers to select the perfect ring that showcases the beauty and brilliance of their chosen diamond.

e. Custom-Designed Rings: For those who wish to create a truly personalized and one-of-a-kind piece, Leibish & Co. offers the opportunity to work with their expert designers and craftsmen. Clients can collaborate with the team to design a unique engagement ring that captures their individual love story and style preferences, incorporating their choice of colored diamonds, gemstones, and precious metals.

A Leibish Custom Design Ring

Each collection in Leibish & Co.'s repertoire demonstrates the company's commitment to exceptional quality, innovative design, and unparalleled craftsmanship. With a vast array of options and customizable features, Leibish & Co. ensures that every customer can find the perfect engagement ring to symbolize their love and commitment.

Design and Craftsmanship

Leibish & Co. prides itself on the meticulous design and craftsmanship that goes into creating each of their engagement rings and fine jewelry pieces. Every piece is expertly crafted, displaying a harmonious marriage between innovative design and masterful artistry.

Their talented team of designers works closely with skilled craftsmen to create breathtaking designs that highlight the natural beauty and vibrant colors of the diamonds and gemstones. This collaboration ensures that each piece showcases the unique characteristics of the stones, resulting in truly captivating and one-of-a-kind jewelry.

Leibish & Co.'s expertise in working with colored diamonds and gemstones is evident in their ability to create designs that enhance and complement the stones' hues and cuts. By carefully selecting the perfect combination of diamonds, gemstones, and precious metals, they ensure that each piece not only reflects the individuality and preferences of the wearer but also exemplifies the finest aspects of the stones themselves.

The craftsmanship behind each Leibish engagement ring is marked by precise attention to detail and a passion for perfection. From the delicate metalwork and intricate settings to the secure placement of each stone, the company's commitment to quality is apparent in every aspect of their creations.

In addition to their exceptional craftsmanship, Leibish & Co. offers a lifetime warranty on their engagement rings, ensuring that your ring remains in pristine condition for years to come. This commitment to customer satisfaction and aftercare demonstrates the company's dedication to providing a truly memorable and lasting experience for their clients.

The unparalleled design and craftsmanship at Leibish & Co. set them apart as a leading name in the world of colored diamonds and gemstone jewelry. When you choose a Leibish engagement ring, you are not only investing in a beautiful piece of jewelry but also in the company's unwavering commitment to excellence and innovation in the realm of colorful brilliance.

Pricing and Value

Leibish & Co. offers a wide range of engagement rings and fine jewelry pieces, catering to various budgets and preferences. While their prices might be higher than some competitors, the value of a Leibish & Co. engagement ring lies in the exceptional quality, craftsmanship, and rarity of their colored diamonds and gemstones.

For those seeking more affordable colored diamond options, James Allen and Blue Nile are worth considering. Both companies offer a selection of colored diamonds at competitive prices, allowing customers to find a beautiful and unique engagement ring within their budget. However, it is essential to note that Leibish & Co.'s expertise and specialization in colored diamonds may provide a more extensive and curated selection of these vibrant stones, as well as designs specifically tailored to enhance their beauty.

If you are in the market for colorless diamonds, Whiteflash is a fantastic option. As a company that specializes in colorless diamonds, Whiteflash offers a broad range of high-quality stones at various price points. Their commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction makes them a top choice for those seeking the perfect colorless diamond engagement ring.

In conclusion, while Leibish & Co. may have a higher price point than some competitors, the value of their engagement rings is evident in the extraordinary quality, design, and rarity of their colored diamonds and gemstones. For customers seeking more affordable colored diamond options, James Allen and Blue Nile are viable alternatives. If colorless diamonds are your preference, Whiteflash is a top choice, ensuring that you find the perfect engagement ring that suits your budget and style.

The Leibish Experience

Shopping for an engagement ring or fine jewelry piece at Leibish & Co. is a personalized, educational, and memorable experience. The company's commitment to providing exceptional customer service ensures that each client receives the individual attention and guidance they need when selecting the perfect ring.

Whether you're visiting their website or one of their international offices, Leibish & Co. offers a comprehensive and informative approach to help you understand the unique characteristics of colored diamonds and gemstones. Their knowledgeable staff is always available to answer questions and provide guidance, ensuring that you make an informed decision when choosing the ideal piece.

The Leibish experience extends beyond the initial purchase, as the company provides ongoing support and aftercare services, including resizing, polishing, and cleaning. Their lifetime warranty further demonstrates their dedication to customer satisfaction and the enduring quality of their creations.


Leibish & Co. is a remarkable choice for those seeking an engagement ring or fine jewelry piece that showcases the vibrant beauty and rarity of colored diamonds and gemstones. Their exceptional quality, innovative designs, and unparalleled craftsmanship set them apart as a leading name in the world of colorful brilliance.

However, it is essential to consider other options based on your specific preferences and budget. For colorless diamonds, Whiteflash is an excellent choice, offering a wide selection of high-quality stones and exceptional customer service. For more affordable colored diamond options, James Allen and Blue Nile are viable alternatives that provide competitive pricing and a range of choices.

Ultimately, the perfect engagement ring is a symbol of your unique love story and commitment. Whether you choose the colorful world of Leibish & Co. or explore other options like Whiteflash, James Allen, or Blue Nile, the most important factor is finding the ring that captures the essence of your love and suits your individual style and preferences.

Leibish Review: 3 out of 5 ★★★ by